Baby’s first Chrismukkah – One family’s approach to the festive season
I love Christmas. Not in a religious way or even a secular but tasteful real-tree-with-John-Lewis-matching-pearlescent-baubles-and-bows sort of way. I love Christmas the British way: tacky, tinsely and soundtracked by Slade, Chris Rea and Wizzard. Where the baby Jesus receives a brief but respectful doff of the Santa hat by way of a school-made nativity display (where the cotton wool sheep are twice as big as their toilet roll shepherds) and where ‘Carols from Kings’ is ignored on the telly as the family tucks into a Nigella Cherry Coke-soaked ham that will see us through from Christmas Eve to New Year. Just as Father Christmas intended.
Like Nigella, my wife is Jewish. Unlike Nigella, she does not eat pork and did not celebrate Christmas growing up; she did celebrate the Chanukah festival, with latkes*, doughnuts and chocolate gelt**, but for her family it was a minor date in the Jewish calendar. Instead, my wife’s big annual family festival was the Pesach Seder meal, where the generations gathered to recount the Jewish escape from bondage in Egypt over a meal of matzah, discussion and salty boiled eggs.
As Jewish heritage passes through the mother’s bloodline to the child, this means our daughter Saffy is also Jewish. We want her to grow up embracing both of her cultures, Jewish and Christmasist, without either one taking precedence. Having a baby girl meant we could neatly skirt any debates on circumcision; so Christmas has been our first big Jewish/gentile crossroad discussion and, as Saffy will be eight months old when Santa Claus comes to town, my wife is worried that the flashing fairy lights of Christmas will catch her eye more than the somber flickering candlelight of Chanukah.
Our search for a happy medium brought us to Chrismukkah, a portmanteau for the interfaith festival born in the early noughties across the Atlantic. Chrismukkah started as a joke plotline in the US TV show The O.C, but is now taken seriously by American Jewish-gentile interfaith families keen to remix the Christmas and Chanukah holidays into something that works for them.
Chrismukkah has its share of critics. In 2004 the Catholic League and the New York Board of Rabbis released a joint statement condemning Chrismukkah as “insulting” to both Jews and Christians, a response that doesn’t seem fitting with the spirit of either season and is a po-faced separatist stance against interfaith togetherness – the expression of which has so far produced such wonderful things as the bacon bagel and, of course, my daughter Saffy.
My wife has always been up for trying something different and this, combined with my love of immediately picking up anything that the grown ups have warned me to leave well alone, made us decide that this December we would deck the halls with boughs of Chrismukkah.
Chrismukkah is a festival without tradition or expectation, so this a chance for my wife and I to reflect on our own customs, see what works, discard what doesn’t and establish our own family traditions. We’re building something from the ground up that Saffy can call her own, develop as we grow together and potentially pass on to her children. It’s important stuff.

So this year our Christmas tree has been rebranded as a Chanukah bush, doughnuts will be offered to guests alongside mince pies and my wife’s menorah complements my stocking on the mantlepiece. On the 25th, dreidels*** will sit next to crackers at the dinner table where latkes will be served alongside the turkey. Every family has its traditions and these will be ours –no greater or lesser than those found in the religions from which they’ve been reinterpreted.
It is our hope that Saffy will not grow up to see herself as Jewish or Gentile, but that she will see herself as Saffy. This is our first step.
Merry Chrissmukkah to all, and to all a good nosh!
**gelt – chocolate coins given to Jewish children on the festival of Chanukah.
***dreidel – a four-sided spinning top, played with during the Jewish holiday of Chanukah.





